Date: February 3, 2025Attorney: Joshua M. Gorsky

If you’re a commercial property owner facing the threat of foreclosure, or just skimming headlines you’ve likely seen the phrase “giving back the keys”.

Although this expression may sound like an informal and straightforward solution, it refers to a  specific legal process known as a deed in lieu of foreclosure. In more practical terms, this means voluntarily handing over ownership of your property to the lender to avoid the process of foreclosure.

What does it really means to “give back the keys” through a deed in lieu of foreclosure? Below, I’ll break down the process and its implications for owners of commercial real estate.

What Is a Deed in Lieu of Foreclosure?

A deed in lieu of foreclosure is a legal arrangement between a borrower (you, the commercial property owner) and your lender, where you transfer ownership of your commercial property to the lender to settle your outstanding mortgage debt. This transfer avoids the lengthy and expensive foreclosure process, but you are voluntarily relinquishing your ownership rights to the property—handing over the keys.

The Mechanics: What “Giving Back the Keys” Really Entails

When people talk about “giving back the keys,” it can sound deceptively simple. However, the process of executing a deed in lieu of foreclosure involves several key steps, legal formalities, and negotiations:

  1. Lender Consent: The first and most critical step is getting lender consent. If the lender believes they would come out better by foreclosing and selling the property themselves, they might decline the offer.
  2. Negotiation of Terms: Once the lender agrees, there is a negotiation of specific terms. Here, owners want to ensure that they are fully released from any further liability and that the lender agrees to forgive any deficiency (the difference between the property’s value upon a sale and what you owe).
  3. Clean Title Requirement: A lender will usually require that the title to the property be clean, meaning no secondary liens, judgments, or other encumbrances on the property. If your property has these issues, they must be cleared up before the lender will accept the deed. This can be more complicated with commercial properties, where you might have liens from contractors, tax authorities, or other creditors.
  4. Finalizing the Agreement: Once everything is agreed upon, you sign the deed, hand it over to the lender, and the mortgage debt is extinguished—assuming no deficiency remains, and you have negotiated a full release.

The Benefits of a Deed in Lieu of Foreclosure

For many commercial property owners, a deed in lieu of foreclosure offers several advantages:

  1. Avoiding Foreclosure: The primary benefit is that you avoid the foreclosure process, which can be long, expensive, and damaging to your business and credit. A foreclosure typically involves court proceedings, which add legal fees, court costs, and stress to an already difficult situation.
  2. Reducing Legal Costs: While you still need legal assistance for negotiating a deed in lieu of foreclosure are generally lower than going through a full foreclosure.
  3. Less Public Exposure: Foreclosures are a matter of public record and can harm your business’s reputation. A deed in lieu will still be while still documented in the land records but is often viewed as a less public and more cooperative resolution.

The Drawbacks to Consider

Though a deed in lieu of foreclosure can be an attractive option, it’s not without its risks and challenges:

  1. Loss of Property: The most obvious downside is that you lose ownership of your commercial property. If market conditions improve after the transfer, you won’t benefit from any appreciation or renewed interest in the property.
  2. Junior Liens and Deficiency Judgments: If there are junior liens (second mortgages, contractor liens, etc.), the lender may refuse the deed in lieu, or you may still be responsible for paying off those other obligations. Additionally, if the value of the property is less than the amount you owe, the lender may seek a deficiency judgment unless you’ve negotiated a waiver as part of the agreement.
  3. Tax Implications: Forgiven debt can sometimes be considered taxable income by the IRS. If the lender forgives a portion of your debt, you may face tax consequences. It’s important to consult with a tax advisor to fully understand the tax ramifications before proceeding.

Is “Giving Back the Keys” Right for You?

A deed in lieu of foreclosure can be a smart move if you’re struggling with an underwater commercial property or facing financial challenges that make continuing mortgage payments impossible. It provides a way to mitigate damage, avoid foreclosure, and settle your debt with the lender without going through the court system. However, “giving back the keys” isn’t a simple or automatic process—it requires negotiation, careful legal planning, and a clear understanding of your financial and legal standing.

Share: