The most interesting businesses often start with a problem the founder could not stop thinking about. For RT Custer, that problem was the story no one was telling about American manufacturing history, the pocket watches produced by factories that no longer exist, built by craftspeople whose work survived long after the companies that employed them disappeared. What started as a passion project became Vortic Watch Company, a business that converts antique American-made pocket watches into wrist watches, and the story behind how it happened is a useful lesson in creative entrepreneurship.
On Episode 29 of Fingerprints on Success with Bill Barrett, Custer shared the thinking behind Vortic, what he learned building a manufacturing business in an era when most products in his category are made overseas, and how he approaches the challenge of building a brand around something genuinely distinctive in a crowded market.
Starting With the Product, Not the Market
Custer’s path to building a company started with an obsession with the product itself before there was any clear business model around it. The antique American pocket watch movements he sources are genuinely irreplaceable: the factories that made them are gone, the craftspeople who made them are gone, and the number of movements that still exist is finite. That scarcity and historical significance are what make Vortic’s products meaningful rather than merely interesting.
His approach to company building reflects that product-first orientation. Rather than identifying a market gap and building a product to fill it, he started with something he believed was worth making and built the market understanding to surround it. The lesson for other entrepreneurs is not that this approach is always right, but that deep product conviction translates into the kind of authentic brand narrative that paid marketing rarely replicates.
Building American Manufacturing When It Wasn’t the Easy Choice
Vortic manufactures in the United States, a choice Custer made deliberately at a time when the economic logic points strongly in the other direction. That choice created real constraints: higher costs, longer timelines, more limited scale. But it also created the authenticity the brand requires. A Vortic watch that told a story about American manufacturing heritage while being made overseas would have been a contradiction that undermined the entire value proposition.
The broader lesson is about the alignment between a brand’s story and its actual operating decisions. Customers of businesses that stand for something specific are sophisticated enough to notice when operational reality contradicts the brand’s claimed values. Building a business that is consistent all the way down, where the product, the process, and the story all reinforce each other, is harder than building one where the story is aspirational and the reality is more pragmatic. It also tends to produce more durable customer relationships.
What Creative Entrepreneurs Need to Know About Building a Business
Custer’s experience reflects a pattern common to creative entrepreneurs: the skills that make you effective at building a distinctive product or brand are not the same skills that make you effective at building a company around that product. Finance, operations, team management, and strategic planning are different disciplines from the creative work that probably drew you to entrepreneurship in the first place. Recognizing that gap and closing it, either through learning or through the right partners, is a critical inflection point for most creative businesses. According to the SCORE Association, lack of business planning and financial management skills are among the leading contributors to small business failure, underscoring why creative founders who build these capabilities early have a significant structural advantage.
Listen to Fingerprints on Success
Fingerprints on Success with Bill Barrett features conversations with entrepreneurs who have built interesting businesses and are willing to share the real story of how they did it. Each episode offers practical perspective for business owners across industries and stages.
To learn more about Mandelbaum Barrett PC and the legal resources available to entrepreneurs and growing businesses, contact Mandelbaum Barrett PC today.